Once you have your Web API developed, before exposing it to your clients, based upon your needs you may need to secure some or all parts of your API Service so that only verified users can access your API service. This securing in ASP.NET can be achieved using the authentication and authorization mechanisms.
Authentication is the process of determining whether someone or something is, in fact, who or what it is claimed to be. By using the authentication mechanism, we make sure that every request received by the Web API service is sent from a client with proper credentials.
A message handler is a class that receives an HTTP request and returns an HTTP response. Message handlers are derived classes from the abstract class HttpMessageHandler
. They are good for cross-cutting concerns that operate at the level of HTTP messages (rather than controller actions). For example, a message handler might:
In a Web API, typically, a series of message handlers are chained together, forming a pattern called delegating handler.
The order in which these handlers are set up is important as they will be executed sequentially.
The most important handler sits at the very top, guarding everything that comes in. If the checks pass, it will pass this request down the chain to the next delegating handler, and so on.
If all goes well, it will then arrive at the API Controller and execute the desired action. However, if any of the checks fail within the handlers, then the request is denied and a response is sent to the client.
With this much theory in hand, now let's write code for our handlers. We will create two message handlers in this article:
In your Web API project, create a folder called MessageHandlers
and add a class APIKeyHandler.cs
.
public class APIKeyHandler : DelegatingHandler { //set a default API key private const string yourApiKey = "X-some-key"; protected override async Task<HttpResponseMessage> SendAsync(HttpRequestMessage request, CancellationToken cancellationToken) { bool isValidAPIKey = false; IEnumerable<string> lsHeaders; //Validate that the api key exists var checkApiKeyExists = request.Headers.TryGetValues("API_KEY", out lsHeaders); if (checkApiKeyExists) { if (lsHeaders.FirstOrDefault().Equals(yourApiKey)) { isValidAPIKey = true; } } //If the key is not valid, return an http status code. if (!isValidAPIKey) return request.CreateResponse(HttpStatusCode.Forbidden, "Bad API Key"); //Allow the request to process further down the pipeline var response = await base.SendAsync(request, cancellationToken); //Return the response back up the chain return response; } }
The APIKeyHandler.cs
inherits from DelegatingHandler
, which in turn inherits from HttpMessageHandler
. This allows us to override the functionality for inspecting an HTTP request and control whether we want to allow this request to flow down the pipeline to the next handler and controller or halt the request by sending a custom response.
In this class, we are achieving this by overriding the SendAsync
method. This method looks for an API key (API_KEY
) in the header of every HTTP request, and passes the request to the controller only if a valid API key is present in the request header.
Now, to see this handler in action, we need to first register it to our application in the Application_Start
method from the Global.asax
file.
GlobalConfiguration.Configuration.MessageHandlers.Add(new APIKeyHandler());
Try calling any method that you have exposed through your Web API controllers and you should see "Bad API Key" as response.
For a demo in this article, I am using the same project and the URLs that I have created in my previous article, "Developing an ASP.NET Web API".
Let's verify that the APIKeyHandler
is working alright by creating an HTTP Request with correct headers. For that, we need to create an HTTP header with key value:
"API_KEY" : "X-some-key"
I am using a Mozilla browser plugin called "HTTP Tool" for creating HTTP request headers here.
The HTTP request is now passed all the way to the controller by the handler.
So our API key check handler is in place now. This secures our Web API to make sure only those clients that are provided with valid API keys can access this service. Next we will look at how we can implement security based on user roles.
Basic authentication, as its name suggests, is the most simple and basic form of authenticating HTTP requests. The client sends Base64-encoded credentials in the Authorize header on every HTTP request, and only if the credentials are verified does the API return the expected response. Basic authentication doesn't require server-side session storage or implementation of cookies as every request is verified by the API.
Once basic authentication implementation in Web API is understood, it will be very easy to hook other forms of authentication. Only the authentication process will be different, and the Web API hooks, where it is done, will be the same.
For verifying user credentials, we create an IPrincipal
object which represents the current security context.
Add a new folder called Security
and a new class TestAPIPrincipal.cs
in it.
public class TestAPIPrincipal : IPrincipal { //Constructor public TestAPIPrincipal(string userName) { UserName = userName; Identity = new GenericIdentity(userName); } public string UserName { get; set; } public IIdentity Identity { get; set; } public bool IsInRole(string role) { if (role.Equals("user")) { return true; } else { return false; } } }
The IIdentity
object associated with the principal has a property called IsAuthenticated
. If the user is authenticated, this property will return true; otherwise, it will return false.
Now, let's create another handler called AuthHandler.cs
.
public class AuthHandler : DelegatingHandler { string _userName = ""; //Method to validate credentials from Authorization //header value private bool ValidateCredentials(AuthenticationHeaderValue authenticationHeaderVal) { try { if (authenticationHeaderVal != null && !String.IsNullOrEmpty(authenticationHeaderVal.Parameter)) { string[] decodedCredentials = Encoding.ASCII.GetString(Convert.FromBase64String( authenticationHeaderVal.Parameter)) .Split(new[] { ':' }); //now decodedCredentials[0] will contain //username and decodedCredentials[1] will //contain password. if (decodedCredentials[0].Equals("username") && decodedCredentials[1].Equals("password")) { _userName = "John Doe"; return true;//request authenticated. } } return false;//request not authenticated. } catch { return false; } } protected override async Task<HttpResponseMessage> SendAsync(HttpRequestMessage request, CancellationToken cancellationToken) { //if the credentials are validated, //set CurrentPrincipal and Current.User if (ValidateCredentials(request.Headers.Authorization)) { Thread.CurrentPrincipal = new TestAPIPrincipal(_userName); HttpContext.Current.User = new TestAPIPrincipal(_userName); } //Execute base.SendAsync to execute default //actions and once it is completed, //capture the response object and add //WWW-Authenticate header if the request //was marked as unauthorized. //Allow the request to process further down the pipeline var response = await base.SendAsync(request, cancellationToken); if (response.StatusCode == HttpStatusCode.Unauthorized && !response.Headers.Contains("WwwAuthenticate")) { response.Headers.Add("WwwAuthenticate", "Basic"); } return response; } }
This class contains a private method ValidateCredentials
, which checks for decoded username and password values from the HTTP request header, and also the SendAsync
method for intercepting the HTTP request.
If the credentials of the client are valid, then the current IPrincipal
object is attached to the current thread, i.e. Thread.CurrentPrincipal
. We also set the HttpContext.Current.User
to make the security context consistent. This allows us to access the current user's details from anywhere in the application.
Once the request is authenticated, base.SendAsync
is called to send the request to the inner handler. If the response contains an HTTP unauthorized header, the code injects a WwwAuthenticate
header with the value Basic
to inform the client that our service expects basic authentication.
Now, we need to register this handler in the Global.Asax
class as we did for our ApiKeyHandler
. Make sure that the AuthHandler
handler is below the first handler registration to make sure of the right order.
GlobalConfiguration.Configuration.MessageHandlers.Add(new APIKeyHandler()); GlobalConfiguration.Configuration.MessageHandlers.Add(new AuthHandler());
But before we can see basic authentication in action, we will first need to implement authorization.
Authorization is verifying whether the authenticated user can perform a particular action or consume a particular resource. This process in Web API happens later in the pipeline, after
authentication and before the controller actions are executed.
ASP.NET MVC Web API provides an authorization filter called AuthorizeAttribute
which verifies the request's IPrincipal
, checks its Identity.IsAuthenticated
property, and returns a 401 Unauthorized
HTTP status if the value is false and the requested action method will not be executed. This filter can be applied in different levels like the controller level or action level, and can be easily applied using the [Authorize]
syntax on top of controllers or actions.
[Authorize] public class ClassifiedsController : ApiController
Once this attribute is set, it will prevent all action methods in the controller from being accessed by unauthorized users.
First our basic authentication handler kicks in to set the current user's identity IPrincipal
object. Then, before this request reaches the controller, AuthorizeAttribute
verifies access to the particular controller/action for the current user.
To see this in action, first let's create an HTTP request without proper credentials.
The access gets denied by the AuthorizeAttribute
.
Now, let's create another request with Authorization header key/value this time as follows:
Authorization: Basic dXNlcm5hbWU6cGFzc3dvcmQ=
Here, the value dXNlcm5hbWU6cGFzc3dvcmQ=
is the Base64-encoded form of username:password
.
This request gets access rights to the controller/action as expected.
This is an example of securing the entire controller's public Actions.
We can also restrict some parts of the controller actions by setting the [Authorize]
attribute at the action level only instead. Doing so will allow us to have both protected and unprotected actions in the same controller.
//[Authorize] public class ClassifiedsController : ApiController { public List<ClassifiedModel> Get(string id) { return ClassifiedService.GetClassifieds(id); } [Authorize] public List<ClassifiedModel> Get() { return ClassifiedService.GetClassifieds(""); }
Another way to have both protected and unprotected actions within the controller is by making use of the [AllowAnonymous]
attribute. When we set the [Authorize]
attribute in the controller level and set the [AllowAnonymous]
attribute for any action inside the controller, that action will skip the [Authorize]
attribute.
It is also possible to filter certain roles and users for access rights. For example, we can have something like [Authorize(Roles = "Admin")]
on the controllers and actions.
Finally, we can also create our own custom authorization attribute depending upon our needs. One of the ways to achieve this is by extending AuthorizeAttribute
.
Say we want to restrict our Web API service to only certain parts of the world by restricting access to users that are not within a certain range of IP address. We can create a custom authorize attribute for this purpose by deriving from the AuthorizeAttribute
class and overriding the IsAuthorized
method.
public class RestrictIPsAttribute: System.Web.Http.AuthorizeAttribute { protected override bool IsAuthorized(HttpActionContext context) { var ip = HttpContext.Current.Request.UserHostAddress; //check for ip here if (ip.Contains("")) { return true; } return false; } }
Once we have our custom Authorize attribute, we can decorate our controllers/actions with it.
[RestrictIPsAttribute] public List<ClassifiedModel> Get() { return ClassifiedService.GetClassifieds(""); }
In this article, we looked at how we can secure our ASP.NET Web API service before exposing the service to the world outside. We looked at how we can authenticate HTTP requests for valid API keys and for valid user credentials. With this much knowledge in hand, I believe we ready to develop any custom security for our APIs.
For those of you who are either just getting started with Laravel or looking to expand your knowledge, site, or application with extensions, we have a variety of things you can study in Envato Market.
I hope you enjoyed reading as much as learning from this article, and remember to leave any questions or comments in the feed below!
The Best Small Business Web Designs by DesignRush
/Create Modern Vue Apps Using Create-Vue and Vite
/Pros and Cons of Using WordPress
/How to Fix the “There Has Been a Critical Error in Your Website” Error in WordPress
How To Fix The “There Has Been A Critical Error in Your Website” Error in WordPress
/How Long Does It Take to Learn JavaScript?
/The Best Way to Deep Copy an Object in JavaScript
/Adding and Removing Elements From Arrays in JavaScript
/Create a JavaScript AJAX Post Request: With and Without jQuery
/5 Real-Life Uses for the JavaScript reduce() Method
/How to Enable or Disable a Button With JavaScript: jQuery vs. Vanilla
/How to Enable or Disable a Button With JavaScript: jQuery vs Vanilla
/Confirm Yes or No With JavaScript
/How to Change the URL in JavaScript: Redirecting
/15+ Best WordPress Twitter Widgets
/27 Best Tab and Accordion Widget Plugins for WordPress (Free & Premium)
/21 Best Tab and Accordion Widget Plugins for WordPress (Free & Premium)
/30 HTML Best Practices for Beginners
/31 Best WordPress Calendar Plugins and Widgets (With 5 Free Plugins)
/25 Ridiculously Impressive HTML5 Canvas Experiments
/How to Implement Email Verification for New Members
/How to Create a Simple Web-Based Chat Application
/30 Popular WordPress User Interface Elements
/Top 18 Best Practices for Writing Super Readable Code
/Best Affiliate WooCommerce Plugins Compared
/18 Best WordPress Star Rating Plugins
/10+ Best WordPress Twitter Widgets
/20+ Best WordPress Booking and Reservation Plugins
/Working With Tables in React: Part Two
/Best CSS Animations and Effects on CodeCanyon
/30 CSS Best Practices for Beginners
/How to Create a Custom WordPress Plugin From Scratch
/10 Best Responsive HTML5 Sliders for Images and Text… and 3 Free Options
/16 Best Tab and Accordion Widget Plugins for WordPress
/18 Best WordPress Membership Plugins and 5 Free Plugins
/25 Best WooCommerce Plugins for Products, Pricing, Payments and More
10 Best WordPress Twitter Widgets
1 /12 Best Contact Form PHP Scripts for 2020
/20 Popular WordPress User Interface Elements
/10 Best WordPress Star Rating Plugins
/12 Best CSS Animations on CodeCanyon
/12 Best WordPress Booking and Reservation Plugins
/12 Elegant CSS Pricing Tables for Your Latest Web Project
/24 Best WordPress Form Plugins for 2020
/14 Best PHP Event Calendar and Booking Scripts
/Create a Blog for Each Category or Department in Your WooCommerce Store
/8 Best WordPress Booking and Reservation Plugins
/Best Exit Popups for WordPress Compared
/Best Exit Popups for WordPress Compared
/11 Best Tab & Accordion WordPress Widgets & Plugins
/12 Best Tab & Accordion WordPress Widgets & Plugins
1New Course: Practical React Fundamentals
/Preview Our New Course on Angular Material
/Build Your Own CAPTCHA and Contact Form in PHP
/Object-Oriented PHP With Classes and Objects
/Best Practices for ARIA Implementation
/Accessible Apps: Barriers to Access and Getting Started With Accessibility
/Dramatically Speed Up Your React Front-End App Using Lazy Loading
/15 Best Modern JavaScript Admin Templates for React, Angular, and Vue.js
/15 Best Modern JavaScript Admin Templates for React, Angular and Vue.js
/19 Best JavaScript Admin Templates for React, Angular, and Vue.js
/New Course: Build an App With JavaScript and the MEAN Stack
/Hands-on With ARIA: Accessibility Recipes for Web Apps
/10 Best WordPress Facebook Widgets
13 /Hands-on With ARIA: Accessibility for eCommerce
/New eBooks Available for Subscribers
/Hands-on With ARIA: Homepage Elements and Standard Navigation
/Site Accessibility: Getting Started With ARIA
/How Secure Are Your JavaScript Open-Source Dependencies?
/New Course: Secure Your WordPress Site With SSL
/Testing Components in React Using Jest and Enzyme
/Testing Components in React Using Jest: The Basics
/15 Best PHP Event Calendar and Booking Scripts
/Create Interactive Gradient Animations Using Granim.js
/How to Build Complex, Large-Scale Vue.js Apps With Vuex
1 /Examples of Dependency Injection in PHP With Symfony Components
/Set Up Routing in PHP Applications Using the Symfony Routing Component
1 /A Beginner’s Guide to Regular Expressions in JavaScript
/Introduction to Popmotion: Custom Animation Scrubber
/Introduction to Popmotion: Pointers and Physics
/New Course: Connect to a Database With Laravel’s Eloquent ORM
/How to Create a Custom Settings Panel in WooCommerce
/Building the DOM faster: speculative parsing, async, defer and preload
1 /20 Useful PHP Scripts Available on CodeCanyon
3 /How to Find and Fix Poor Page Load Times With Raygun
/Introduction to the Stimulus Framework
/Single-Page React Applications With the React-Router and React-Transition-Group Modules
12 Best Contact Form PHP Scripts
1 /Getting Started With the Mojs Animation Library: The ShapeSwirl and Stagger Modules
/Getting Started With the Mojs Animation Library: The Shape Module
/Getting Started With the Mojs Animation Library: The HTML Module
/Project Management Considerations for Your WordPress Project
/8 Things That Make Jest the Best React Testing Framework
/Creating an Image Editor Using CamanJS: Layers, Blend Modes, and Events
/New Short Course: Code a Front-End App With GraphQL and React
/Creating an Image Editor Using CamanJS: Applying Basic Filters
/Creating an Image Editor Using CamanJS: Creating Custom Filters and Blend Modes
/Modern Web Scraping With BeautifulSoup and Selenium
/Challenge: Create a To-Do List in React
1 /Deploy PHP Web Applications Using Laravel Forge
/Getting Started With the Mojs Animation Library: The Burst Module
/10 Things Men Can Do to Support Women in Tech
/A Gentle Introduction to Higher-Order Components in React: Best Practices
/Challenge: Build a React Component
/A Gentle Introduction to HOC in React: Learn by Example
/A Gentle Introduction to Higher-Order Components in React
/Creating Pretty Popup Messages Using SweetAlert2
/Creating Stylish and Responsive Progress Bars Using ProgressBar.js
/18 Best Contact Form PHP Scripts for 2022
/How to Make a Real-Time Sports Application Using Node.js
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Delete Post
/Set Up an OAuth2 Server Using Passport in Laravel
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Edit Post
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Add Post
/Introduction to Mocking in Python
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Show Post
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Home
/Creating a Blogging App Using Angular & MongoDB: Login
/Creating Your First Angular App: Implement Routing
/Persisted WordPress Admin Notices: Part 4
/Creating Your First Angular App: Components, Part 2
/Persisted WordPress Admin Notices: Part 3
/Creating Your First Angular App: Components, Part 1
/How Laravel Broadcasting Works
/Persisted WordPress Admin Notices: Part 2
/Create Your First Angular App: Storing and Accessing Data
/Persisted WordPress Admin Notices: Part 1
/Error and Performance Monitoring for Web & Mobile Apps Using Raygun
/Using Luxon for Date and Time in JavaScript
7 /How to Create an Audio Oscillator With the Web Audio API
/How to Cache Using Redis in Django Applications
/20 Essential WordPress Utilities to Manage Your Site
/Introduction to API Calls With React and Axios
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular 4: HTTP
/Rapid Web Deployment for Laravel With GitHub, Linode, and RunCloud.io
/Beginners Guide to Angular 4: Routing
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular 4: Services
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular 4: Components
/Creating a Drop-Down Menu for Mobile Pages
/Introduction to Forms in Angular 4: Writing Custom Form Validators
/10 Best WordPress Booking & Reservation Plugins
/Getting Started With Redux: Connecting Redux With React
/Getting Started With Redux: Learn by Example
/Getting Started With Redux: Why Redux?
/How to Auto Update WordPress Salts
/How to Download Files in Python
/Eloquent Mutators and Accessors in Laravel
1 /10 Best HTML5 Sliders for Images and Text
/Site Authentication in Node.js: User Signup
/Creating a Task Manager App Using Ionic: Part 2
/Creating a Task Manager App Using Ionic: Part 1
/Introduction to Forms in Angular 4: Reactive Forms
/Introduction to Forms in Angular 4: Template-Driven Forms
/24 Essential WordPress Utilities to Manage Your Site
/25 Essential WordPress Utilities to Manage Your Site
/Get Rid of Bugs Quickly Using BugReplay
1 /Manipulating HTML5 Canvas Using Konva: Part 1, Getting Started
/10 Must-See Easy Digital Downloads Extensions for Your WordPress Site
/22 Best WordPress Booking and Reservation Plugins
/Understanding ExpressJS Routing
/15 Best WordPress Star Rating Plugins
/Creating Your First Angular App: Basics
/Inheritance and Extending Objects With JavaScript
/Introduction to the CSS Grid Layout With Examples
1Performant Animations Using KUTE.js: Part 5, Easing Functions and Attributes
Performant Animations Using KUTE.js: Part 4, Animating Text
/Performant Animations Using KUTE.js: Part 3, Animating SVG
/New Course: Code a Quiz App With Vue.js
/Performant Animations Using KUTE.js: Part 2, Animating CSS Properties
Performant Animations Using KUTE.js: Part 1, Getting Started
/10 Best Responsive HTML5 Sliders for Images and Text (Plus 3 Free Options)
/Single-Page Applications With ngRoute and ngAnimate in AngularJS
/Deferring Tasks in Laravel Using Queues
/Site Authentication in Node.js: User Signup and Login
/Working With Tables in React, Part Two
/Working With Tables in React, Part One
/How to Set Up a Scalable, E-Commerce-Ready WordPress Site Using ClusterCS
/New Course on WordPress Conditional Tags
/TypeScript for Beginners, Part 5: Generics
/Building With Vue.js 2 and Firebase
6 /Best Unique Bootstrap JavaScript Plugins
/Essential JavaScript Libraries and Frameworks You Should Know About
/Vue.js Crash Course: Create a Simple Blog Using Vue.js
/Build a React App With a Laravel RESTful Back End: Part 1, Laravel 5.5 API
/API Authentication With Node.js
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular: HTTP
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular: Routing
/Beginners Guide to Angular: Routing
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular: Services
/Beginner’s Guide to Angular: Components
/How to Create a Custom Authentication Guard in Laravel
/Learn Computer Science With JavaScript: Part 3, Loops
/Build Web Applications Using Node.js
/Learn Computer Science With JavaScript: Part 4, Functions
/Learn Computer Science With JavaScript: Part 2, Conditionals
/Create Interactive Charts Using Plotly.js, Part 5: Pie and Gauge Charts
/Create Interactive Charts Using Plotly.js, Part 4: Bubble and Dot Charts
Create Interactive Charts Using Plotly.js, Part 3: Bar Charts
/Awesome JavaScript Libraries and Frameworks You Should Know About
/Create Interactive Charts Using Plotly.js, Part 2: Line Charts
/Bulk Import a CSV File Into MongoDB Using Mongoose With Node.js
/Build a To-Do API With Node, Express, and MongoDB
/Getting Started With End-to-End Testing in Angular Using Protractor
/TypeScript for Beginners, Part 4: Classes
/Object-Oriented Programming With JavaScript
/10 Best Affiliate WooCommerce Plugins Compared
/Stateful vs. Stateless Functional Components in React
/Make Your JavaScript Code Robust With Flow
/Build a To-Do API With Node and Restify
/Testing Components in Angular Using Jasmine: Part 2, Services
/Testing Components in Angular Using Jasmine: Part 1
/Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 6: Tags
/React Crash Course for Beginners, Part 3
/React Crash Course for Beginners, Part 2
/React Crash Course for Beginners, Part 1
/Set Up a React Environment, Part 4
1 /Set Up a React Environment, Part 3
/New Course: Get Started With Phoenix
/Set Up a React Environment, Part 2
/Set Up a React Environment, Part 1
/Command Line Basics and Useful Tricks With the Terminal
/How to Create a Real-Time Feed Using Phoenix and React
/Build a React App With a Laravel Back End: Part 2, React
/Build a React App With a Laravel RESTful Back End: Part 1, Laravel 9 API
/Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 5: Profile Page
/Pagination in CodeIgniter: The Complete Guide
/JavaScript-Based Animations Using Anime.js, Part 4: Callbacks, Easings, and SVG
/JavaScript-Based Animations Using Anime.js, Part 3: Values, Timeline, and Playback
/Learn to Code With JavaScript: Part 1, The Basics
/10 Elegant CSS Pricing Tables for Your Latest Web Project
/Getting Started With the Flux Architecture in React
/Getting Started With Matter.js: The Composites and Composite Modules
Getting Started With Matter.js: The Engine and World Modules
/10 More Popular HTML5 Projects for You to Use and Study
/Understand the Basics of Laravel Middleware
/Iterating Fast With Django & Heroku
/Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 4: Update & Delete Posts
/Creating a jQuery Plugin for Long Shadow Design
/How to Register & Use Laravel Service Providers
2 /Unit Testing in React: Shallow vs. Static Testing
/Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 3: Add & Display Post
/Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 2: User Sign-Up
20 /Creating a Blogging App Using React, Part 1: User Sign-In
/Creating a Grocery List Manager Using Angular, Part 2: Managing Items
/9 Elegant CSS Pricing Tables for Your Latest Web Project
/Dynamic Page Templates in WordPress, Part 3
/Angular vs. React: 7 Key Features Compared
/Creating a Grocery List Manager Using Angular, Part 1: Add & Display Items
New eBooks Available for Subscribers in June 2017
/Create Interactive Charts Using Plotly.js, Part 1: Getting Started
/The 5 Best IDEs for WordPress Development (And Why)
/33 Popular WordPress User Interface Elements
/New Course: How to Hack Your Own App
/How to Install Yii on Windows or a Mac
/What Is a JavaScript Operator?
/How to Register and Use Laravel Service Providers
/
waly Good blog post. I absolutely love this…